It's all because the prize is an exclusive...otherwise we'd just be voting for a naked female custom.
This.
Seriously though, exactly why I entered a Laser carrying T-Rex instead of a half naked amazon. I have used the 3 guidelines mentioned (custom quality, bio, and actual match-up) in my voting decision for the most part.
The exception being the underdog vote. On a few occasions I have voted for the underdog because I thought it was a solid custom I loved, but had the misfortune of being paired against a custom that was just on another level all-together. The vote simply gave a nod to a custom that deserved props on it's own but would not win anyway. Just to be clear, never has an underdog vote from me overthrown the favorite. It has aided in halting a total runaway though. LOL, may have even made someone who thought they were a shoe-in sweat.
My personal top ten favorites in no particular order:
Budo Fett (loved Vader too, but Fett had an edge)
Joker
Captian Zargon
Max Ray
Hulk
Oklahoma Don
Doom Space Marine
Ba'al
Harry Dresden
Gi Ty Pham
There were many others I liked.......Stallone, Custodian, oni, etc. but these would be the ten I walked away with if I were told to take ten home with me. Due to match-ups a few of my favorites could never advance far. The Dresden-Ba'al match was difficult in particular.
My personal favorite match to date has been the Gi Ty Pham-Stallone. The trash talk/pics was done perfectly. The voting also reflected the agony of choosing one of these vs. the other. This was a very close match all around.
Both customs were excellent and fun to watch battle. Even though I thought a jedi would win in this match-up, Stallone has my respect.
Before the brackets started my top four predictions were:
Oklahoma Don
Hulk
Captian Zargon
Max Ray
I thought it would end up being Don who eliminated Rex. However due to the way the match-ups landed, I am not sure who will fell Rex and who will end up in the top four. I think OverLord may break into the top four. Not one of my personal favorite characters, but a solid outstanding custom that has the quality to beat out many of my personal picks. The Joker or Blade also may take a top four spot.
I am also not so sure of a Hulk-Blade match-up as I once was. What would happen if Blade sipped on some Hulk blood? Got me rethinking that match-up if it happens.
I am going to be daring and predict Max Ray vs the Hulk as the final match. I am far less confident about this being the final match as I was before the brackets were listed and the voting started. I could see some twists shaking things up as the brackets continue.
Next week Rex does battle again, so the trash talk will start back up from him. He of course thinks all the contestants look......delicious.