You are absolutely spot on in my defaulting to wanting a more realistic, modernized Joe team for JoeClass. I know not everybody wants that, but I think there are a lot of us who do. Not scientific, and obviously a small sample, but just a snapshot of how the fandom (at least the ones motivated enough to participate) is torn on this:
Do I think that 79% of all Joe fans want improved/modernized versions for JoeClass? No, but the percentage is substantial. I also understand that Hasbro has to try to navigate this. My argument is that they are doing it poorly, to the detriment of the campaign. They are now trying to have it both ways in a single collection.
I think Hasbro started off on the right foot with a bunch of offerings to give everybody a chance to get what they wanted from GI Joe 2020's:
- For the purist retro collector: Retro 4" and then Retro 6", and supposedly an O-ring line
- For the modernist: Classified 6"
- For the Cartoon enthusiast: Super 7s and ReAction figs (farmed out to another company)
The problems began when they decided to reduce offerings from their retro lines (too many lines/not enough interest/other reasons?) and decided to just incorporate all that into JoeClass instead. Now they took and bunched all the retro fans in with the modernist fans who were already supporting that line, at least partially due to the updated styling. And now they have to try to cater to both.
I think that, at least for me, has pushed me away from the already expensive Haslabs. If the HT would have simply concentrated on providing a modernized version instead of an over-armed super HISS and had they chosen to offer more value over nostalgia, gimmicks and repaints, I'd have been onboard. Maybe others decided it was the only shot at getting it and just went for it, but I just couldn't justify it. I have a hard time spending significant cash for a schizophrenic offering that can't decide if it's new and improved or retro and obscure.
Now I've found myself in the same boat with the DF. Knowing it's already expensive for a toy, I was leaning toward getting it anyway, seeing how it was a modernized, upgraded version with a very good, updated version of Ripcord. I was hoping that would be the trend the rest of the way. Instead, since we are trying to placate both crowds and cater to the "we must produce gurlz!!!" mafia, we end up with what can only be characterized as a disappointment to most:
Again, not scientific, but trending from all the videos I've seen on the topic.