I think he looks really good, but I'm just not that into S2 characters. They just don't have the charm of the Ark crew. It feels like they tried too hard to give them all a gimmick. Mirage, Bluestreak, and Wheeljack have very distinct personalities, but not over-the-top, in-yo-face. Warpath, Powerglide, Hoist, Seaspray... they border on jar-jar territory for me.
It's funny, I'm not normally a "scale guy" like eddie, but in this case, I kinda get it. While Soundwave and Megatron alt modes size never bothered me, when there were multiple characters that turned into basically the same thing but were very different sizes, THAT bothered me. It's more of a consistency thing than a scale thing I suppose. Huffer and Prime being dramatically different... that bothered me. Air Raid and Starscream, both F-15 jets but very different in size, that bothered me.
I'm really not a scale guy, but there are examples that bother me lots more than others. It's completely illogical. But for my collection, 'bot mode scale accuracy is waaaaaaay more important than anything they do with alt-mode.